万维读者网>世界游戏论坛>帖子
印度历史简列(一个网友的)和AI的反驳和马克思的话
送交者: 火树 2025-03-27 14:03:18 于 [世界游戏论坛]

History that Bollywood won’t tell you: 1. Around 1500 BC, the Aryans entered from the Khyber Pass, colonized India, and created the caste system;2. At the end of the 6th century BC, the Persians defeated the Aryans and began to colonize India; 3. In 327 BC, the Macedonians Colonize India; 4. Beginning in the early 2nd century BC, Bactrian Greeks, Cypriots and Parthians invaded India; 5. In the 2nd century BC, the Yuezhi people who nomadically lived in the Hexi Corridor invaded India; 6. In the middle of the 1st century AD , the Kushan Xihou Tribe, one of the five Xihous of the Dayue clan, unified the five tribes and invaded India to establish the Kushan Empire; 7. In the 5th century AD, the descendants of the Central Asian Ser race and the Dayue clan of the Han Dynasty colonized India; 8 , from the 7th century AD, peoples dominated by Islamic culture began to invade India continuously; 9. In the 8th century AD, the Arab Empire occupied India; 10. In the 11th century AD, the Islamic Turks invaded India; 11. In 1526, the Mongols Colonized India and established the Mughal Empire; 12, the British...There is no India in the world, only colonies of the British Empire. India is the longest colonized region in the world, having been colonized for more than 2,800 years.Most Indians don’t even know where they are from when they look in the mirror.After the British left, they left behind beggars on the streets.

Chat GPT:

Your perspective presents a critical historical interpretation of India's past, focusing on invasions and foreign rule. However, while it is true that the Indian subcontinent has experienced waves of migration, conquest, and colonization over thousands of years, framing its history purely in terms of continuous subjugation oversimplifies a highly complex and dynamic civilization.

A More Nuanced Look at Indian History:

  1. Aryan Migration Theory (c. 1500 BCE) – The idea that Indo-Aryans entered India through the Khyber Pass and imposed the caste system is debated. While linguistic and genetic studies suggest an influx of people from Central Asia, there is no definitive evidence of a violent "colonization." The caste system evolved over time, likely influenced by various socio-economic and religious factors.

  2. Persian and Macedonian Invasions (6th–4th Century BCE) – The Achaemenid Empire controlled parts of northwestern India, but its influence was limited. Alexander the Great briefly invaded in 327 BCE, but his rule did not last beyond his death. The Mauryan Empire emerged soon after, expelling the Greeks and creating one of India's most powerful states.

  3. Greco-Bactrian, Scythian, and Kushan Influence (2nd Century BCE – 5th Century CE) – Various Central Asian groups, including the Yuezhi (who later formed the Kushan Empire), established rule over parts of India. However, they assimilated into Indian culture rather than simply "colonizing" it. The Kushans, for instance, promoted Buddhism, trade, and cultural exchanges.

  4. Islamic Invasions (7th–16th Century CE) – The early Arab incursions in Sindh (8th century) had limited impact. Later, Turkic and Afghan dynasties (Delhi Sultanate) and finally the Mughals (1526–1857) ruled much of India. While these rulers introduced new administrative and cultural influences, they also integrated with Indian traditions. The Mughal Empire, in particular, saw periods of prosperity, architecture, and economic growth.

  5. British Rule (1757–1947 CE) – The British systematically colonized India, exploited its economy, and left behind deep scars. However, reducing post-colonial India to "beggars" ignores the resilience of its people. India, despite challenges, emerged as an independent nation and has since developed into one of the world's largest economies.

India: A Story of Resilience, Not Just Colonization

While foreign rule played a role in shaping Indian history, India has never been a passive colony—it has always absorbed, resisted, and transformed external influences. Powerful indigenous empires like the Mauryas, Guptas, Cholas, Vijayanagar, Marathas, and Sikhs have shaped Indian civilization just as much as external forces.

Instead of viewing India only through the lens of subjugation, a more accurate perspective would recognize its ability to adapt, resist, and influence even its conquerors. India was never just a colony—it was a cradle of civilization that continuously reinvented itself.


Karl Marx 1853:"Indian society has no history at all, at least no known history. What we call its history, is but the history of the successive intruders who founded their empires on the passive basis of that unresisting and unchanging society. The question, therefore, is not whether the English had a right to conquer India, but whether we are to prefer India conquered by the Turk, by the Persian, by the Russian, to India conquered by the Briton."


0.00%(0) 0.00%(0) 0.00%(0)
当前新闻共有0条评论
笔  名 (必选项):
密  码 (必选项):
注册新用户
标  题 (必选项):
内  容 (选填项):